NOREEN: Coloradans have repudiated TABOR and its author

BARRY NOREEN Updated: December 23, 2011 at 12:00 am • Published: December 23, 2011

It’s the prevailing mythology that the state constitutional provision known as the Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights is as strong as ever; that convicted tax cheat Doug Bruce’s triumph has weathered all challenges.

That notion is a simply false.

Truth: Immediately after TABOR’s passage in 1992, voters in special districts, cities and counties across the state began approving “de-Brucing” measures, so their governments could still function the way the voters wanted.

As of 2004, when The Gazette published an in-depth look at the de-Brucings, it was obvious that TABOR was being repudiated far and wide:

• 97 percent of Colorado’s school districts had approved some kind of de-Brucing measure.

• Voters in 43 of Colorado’s 64 counties had completely eliminated TABOR’s restrictive tax-and-spending limits, while 12 others have enacted partial de-Brucings.

• At the time of the story, there had been 418 de-Brucing elections in Colorado cities, and about a third of those eliminated TABOR.

Hundreds of special districts (no one knows the precise number) have eliminated or sharply curtailed TABOR, including the tiny Tri-County Fire Protection District in conservative eastern El Paso County, which lies in what used to be Bruce’s county commission district. In 2002, the fire district faced a legal conundrum: It had to replace a broken down truck at a cost of $10,000, which had to come from the district’s reserve fund.

A state law wisely requires special districts to maintain reserve funds. The district didn’t have the money to restore its reserve, so it had to go to voters for a tax increase and a TABOR exemption. The voters approved the de-Brucing.

The district just wanted to put out a few fires, and TABOR wouldn’t allow it. You won’t find a simpler example for why TABOR’s crazy math doesn’t work.

Finally in 2005, after years of raiding trust funds, state government had no money left to pay for higher education. Without a statewide de-Brucing of some kind, TABOR’s math would have dealt a deadly blow to universities, colleges and community colleges.

Then-Gov. Bill Owens, a longtime TABOR supporter, agreed to a five-year TABOR time-out known as Referendum C. It passed, but because the state spiraled into recession, substantial budget cuts had to be made, anyway.

Many conservatives have agreed to de-Brucings, because in the end, TABOR isn’t about left-vs.-right, as Douglas Bruce would have you believe. It’s just about poor math.

Last week, Bruce’s dubious bookkeeping resulted in a felony conviction for tax evasion.

It’s time for everyone to admit TABOR’s math is just as flawed.

Listen to Barry Noreen on KRDO NewsRadio 105.5 FM and 1240 AM at 6:35 a.m. on Fridays and read his blog updates at gazette.com

blogs/barrysblog

 

Comment Policy
Colorado Springs Gazette has disabled the comments for this article.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
APR
23
APR
24
APR
25
APR
26
APR
27
APR
28
APR
29
APR
30
MAY
1
MAY
2
MAY
3
MAY
4
MAY
5
MAY
6
Advertisement